
David S. Dockery & American Evangelicalism
Southwestern Journal of Theology
Volume 68, No. 2 - Spring 2026
Editor: Malcolm B. Yarnell III
The Nicene Creed: A Scriptural, Historical, and Theological Commentary. By Jared Ortiz and Daniel A. Keating. Grand Rapids: Baker, 2024, 240 pp., $24.99.
Are contemporary Christians still interested in putting their faithful journey in the declarative statements that are considered as far-removed from real life? What is the meaning of finding truth and keeping one’s conviction within the context of ongoing change in the world? Ever since the first century, the Christian faith has demonstrated the mystery of God the Trinity from which the fundamental framework of Christianity has been revealed in various doctrines. The Nicene Creed functions as an introduction to the mysterious realm of the Triune God according to the authors of the book: “That God is one and three at the same time means that we are dealing with a reality not of this world. That Christ has two natures at the same time means we are dealing with a transcendent reality that goes beyond our common and even advanced ways of thinking” (11). Ortiz and Keating are not just leaving the mysterious narrative of the Nicene Creed in the first century. Rather, they are orienting the central mysteries toward real life in the twenty-first century.
Made up of six chapters, the book, focusing on both internal and external characteristics of each person of the Trinity, deserves the subtitle in elaborating on God himself. The mystery of God the Trinity revealed in the Nicene Creed does not know how to compromise regarding who God is: “Only because God is not a part of the whole, but the transcendent creator of the whole, is it possible to say that one God can also be three. In the world, each thing is its own thing. … But God is not a part of the world, so it is not a contradiction to say that each person of the Trinity is fully God and yet there is only one God” (71). The same logic of the mystery is to be applicable to each person of the Trinity, especially to the Son and the Spirit. Some from the perspective of Arius argue that the Father is the only true God, which implies the Son and the Spirit are considered as “having a subordinate divinity, sharing in the Father’s divinity but in a lesser way” (88). However, the mystery of the Trinity confirms the principle in eternity, “to be born or begotten communicates a sharing in the same nature” (83).
The mystery of the Trinity in the Nicene Creed also clearly makes an emphasis on the redemption through the incarnate Son. The Trinitarian interpretation of the Nicene Creed reminds us that “the core of the gospel is the story of our salvation” (106). It is because the redemption can only be possible by two descents of Jesus Christ who lived and accomplished the mystery on earth: descending to assume our “sin-impacted nature” and descending to die on a cross (116).
With the mystery of the Holy Spirit, the authors lead the narrative of the Nicene Creed to the final station. “Why does the Bible call the Third Person of the Trinity by the name ‘Holy Spirit,’ a name that seems equally applicable to the Father and the Son?” (145). Two reasons are provided: first, the Spirit is the “breath” of God that can make people animated; the second point or reason why the “Holy Spirit,” with the concept of the Filioque, delivers the lofty work of the Holy Spirit that causes the body of believers to be holy through his effective indwelling within us (146). God’s ultimate goal toward us is that “we should be brought into the very communion of the Father, Son, and Spirit” because “God is a communion of persons who created us for communion with himself and with each other” (162, 189).
Contemporary Christians might be hungry for stories, which perhaps insinuates they are casting themselves into the cultural trend or atmosphere of drifting apart from the truth expressed in statements or declaration, as the authors are concerned. Where are the doctrines that we believe as fundamental and on which we can rely? Do we live the mystery of the essential teachings of the Bible in reality? This book guides us on a faithful journey on which we can hold through our lives.