Post

Augustine’s 4 Rules for Your Church Potluck

6 min read

Setting a Place for the Bishop

Every so often, churches prepare for a gathering, guided by long-established standards and principles. This service predates your oldest church members, even your church’s own liturgy. It is not the preaching or the music, but a sacred meal: the blessed church potluck.

Far from being indifferent to a humble potluck, Augustine loved a good shared meal.

While some might question its spiritual weight, sharing meals is an act of Christian discipleship practiced since the early church, as seen in Acts 2:42–45, where believers broke bread and shared all things in common. The theological basis for the potluck is strong. But what if one of history’s most revered Christian thinkers showed up today? What if Augustine of Hippo (354–430 AD) joined your family Thanksgiving or church potluck? What manner and rules would he expect? Far from being indifferent to a humble potluck, Augustine loved a good shared meal. However, he would bring a few key house rules worth considering today.

Rule 1: Guard the Table’s Talk

Augustine’s biographer, Possidius, described the bishop’s table as simple yet deeply hospitable. Meats, vegetables, and wine were shared freely, but talk was carefully governed. Possidius records that Augustine had a strict rule against slander, having an inscription carved directly into his table: “Who slanders the name of an absent friend may not as guest at this table attend.” For Augustine, shared meals were for edifying fellowship rather than malicious gossip. The feast was meant to nourish both body and soul, with conversation functioning as a true means of grace rather than destructive chatter.

Applying this rule today means guarding our words at family and church tables alike. Speaking charitably about those who are absent ensures that grace and mercy remain the true main course. When we speak with warmth, love, and protection over others, our gatherings reflect the peace and charity of Christ. How might your potluck reflect the culture of the community? Is it one filled with gracious speech “seasoned with salt” (Col 4:6), or one that is as sour as Aunt Tilda’s homemade pickled gherkins? Let gracious speech lead our fellowship around the Thanksgiving table.

Rule 2: Remember That Everything Is Received

While not strictly about dining, Augustine’s core theological insights connect directly to thanksgiving during meals. In refuting Pelagius, he relied heavily on 1 Corinthians 4:7: “What do you have that you did not receive?” Reflecting in On the Predestination of the Saints (3.7), Augustine noted how he once viewed faith as something generated internally, but later recognized that even faith itself is a sovereign gift from God. This perspective dismantles human pride and instills profound humility.

Thus, the potluck functions as a practical illustration of grace. No participant consumes only what they personally prepared; each receives from the abundance of others. Even those unable to contribute a dish are fully welcomed to partake. Spiritually, we bring nothing of merit to God; He graciously supplies everything necessary for life and salvation, leaving us with gratitude as our only fitting response.

The potluck functions as a practical illustration of grace.

The potluck also reflects Paul’s imagery in 1 Corinthians 12: many distinct members—or dishes—gathered under a single head. We honor one another by receiving these gifts with thanksgiving. Though taking a helping of a mysterious Jell-O mold remains optional, our mutual love and gratitude demonstrate that we belong to Christ (John 13:35).

Rule 3: Enjoy the Gift, Love the Giver

Augustine teaches that we can enjoy the Creator through the gifts He has given. Our temptation, however, is to enjoy the gifts and forget the Giver altogether. In Book One of On Christian Teaching, Augustine makes his famous distinction between “use” and “enjoyment”: God is most to be enjoyed, and the things of this world are not ends in themselves but means to a greater enjoyment of God. He pictures exiles traveling home from a foreign land. If the pleasures of the journey delight them so much that they begin to enjoy what they should only use, they lose the desire to reach their homeland. Their love stops short of its goal.

Augustine also recognized how easily Christians fix their eyes on what is in front of them rather than what is above. In Confessions 10.31, he admits his own temptation to eat and drink beyond what is necessary. A potluck or Thanksgiving meal is certainly cause for celebration, but taking in more than we need may reveal a greater love for the gift than for the Giver. And then there is the day after Thanksgiving, practically a holiday for consumerism and indulgence.

Augustine’s third table rule, then, is not to despise the gifts but to enjoy them properly. Creation and the culinary delights of the potluck invite a pleasure that points upward.

Rule 4: Say “Deo Gratias”

Augustine’s fourth table rule crowns the others: giving thanks to God. This is not a seasonal mood but a habit of speech that marks the Christian table and the Christian life. Preaching on Psalm 133, Augustine notes the custom of greeting one another with Deo gratias (“Thanks be to God”). The schismatic Donatists mocked it; their own slogan, Deo laudes (“Praise to God”), was shouted by zealots who left terror in their wake. Augustine replied, “Is it not right for a brother to give thanks to God when he meets his brother? . . . You find in our Deo gratias an excuse for derision, but people find in your Deo laudes a cause for weeping.”

The potluck is a liturgical test kitchen, training our speech and forming thankful hearts.

The Donatists’ idea was half-baked, lacking biblical ingredients. Let others mock; when Christians gather, we give thanks, heeding Paul’s call to rejoice, pray, and give thanks always (1 Thess 5:16–18). Thanks for the meal; whatever its contents or circumstances, it is as natural as eating. The potluck is a liturgical test kitchen, training our speech and forming thankful hearts.

Conclusion: A Foretaste of the Final Feast

So if one of history’s most influential Christian thinkers showed up at your Thanksgiving potluck, he wouldn’t come alone. Augustine would bring the biblical conviction that all things come from God and are to be enjoyed not for their own sake but for the sake of enjoying God. Our pumpkin pies and green bean casseroles are small tokens of God’s greatest gift, salvation. The gathering in the fellowship hall or dining room is a foretaste of the heavenly banquet. In City of God, Augustine described God as the end of our desires, “seen without end, loved without satiation, and praised without weariness.” His table rules sharpen our hunger for what is eternal. The paper plate is merely a rehearsal for the feast that awaits the faithful, when “we shall be still and see, see and love, love and praise.” Now that is something worth giving thanks for.

Coleman M. Ford

Written by

Coleman M. Ford

Assistant Professor of Humanities at Texas Baptist College

More by this author
More Resources
Blog Post

View All

It’s Wednesday afternoon. I wrapped up work early, and I’m opening my Bible. This week,...

Author: Angie Elkins

Chaplaincy seems to be among the fastest growing ministries in America. Twenty years ago, few...

Author: James Spivey

How do you make a playlist? More than one process has been used over the...

Author: Marcus Waldren Brown